Center speaker help S2 vs DUO

[ilovesound]

Hello,

I currently have a 3.1 setup with 3 S2s. My question to the community is if the DUO LCR RIBBON MINI-MONITOR is better at being a center then my S2 center. I like the form factor more but is a better center? I know there's a few threads on this but I find people keep changing the topic to other speakers I'm not in the market for, I just want to compare the S2 and DUO ribbon. Thank you all.

[ahender]

Hello,

I currently have a 3.1 setup with 3 S2s. My question to the community is if the DUO LCR RIBBON MINI-MONITOR is better at being a center then my S2 center. I like the form factor more but is a better center? I know there's a few threads on this but I find people keep changing the topic to other speakers I'm not in the market for, I just want to compare the S2 and DUO ribbon. Thank you all.

From a post from Dave:

“This depends. The Duo center only becomes the better center channel option compared to the Sierra-2/2EX if using a subwoofer and if the Sierra-2/2EX can only be positioned horizontally. If no sub, or if the S2 center can be placed vertically - it is not the better center.”

This applies to the current Duo. Not sure about the Duo V2.

[ilovesound]

Thanks for the info. I do have a sub, it's a HSU and my center S2 is the horizontal center version.

[ilovesound]

From a post from Dave:

“This depends. The Duo center only becomes the better center channel option compared to the Sierra-2/2EX if using a subwoofer and if the Sierra-2/2EX can only be positioned horizontally. If no sub, or if the S2 center can be placed vertically - it is not the better center.”

This applies to the current Duo. Not sure about the Duo V2.

One question, if you're saying the Sierra 2 is better if placed vertical is it as easy as just rotating the Sierra center tweeter position and standing it up? Would I need to do anything else other then that?

[Mag_Neato]

One question, if you're saying the Sierra 2 is better if placed vertical is it as easy as just rotating the Sierra center tweeter position and standing it up? Would I need to do anything else other then that?

That's all you need to do. The only other difference between the standard Sierra-2 and if you have the center channel version, bought as a center from Ascend, is that the grill on the center version is longer so it covers the entire baffle.

[ilovesound]

That's all you need to do. The only other difference between the standard Sierra-2 and if you have the center channel version, bought as a center from Ascend, is that the grill on the center version is longer so it covers the entire baffle.

That's great, thanks. I'm going to try this and see if it really sounds that much better standing up as the center. If it does I may just use the money I was saving for the Duo and put it towards buying EX upgrade kits for all 3 Sierras.

[msound]

That's great, thanks. I'm going to try this and see if it really sounds that much better standing up as the center. If it does I may just use the money I was saving for the Duo and put it towards buying EX upgrade kits for all 3 Sierras.

Upgrading all three to ex and standing up the center Channel would be the preferred method in my opinion.

[Bruce Watson]

I currently have a 3.1 setup with 3 S2s. My question to the community is if the DUO LCR RIBBON MINI-MONITOR is better at being a center then my S2 center. I like the form factor more but is a better center?

I have an S-2 center, disconnected and boxed up, because I replaced it with a Duo when the Duo first came out (don't have physical room for the Horizon). To me the Duo is a good step up from the S-2 (horizontal, with the tweeter rotated 90 degrees). I'm using a pair of Rythmik subs, so bass handling isn't an issue with the rest of the setup.

What the Duo does better than the S-2 is make the dialog somehow crisper and cleaner. It brings dialog forward just a bit without making it louder. The end result is dialog that is more intelligible. And it's not just me -- wife hears it just the same. In fact it was her insistence that the S-2 center wasn't cutting it that got me to buy the Duo in the first place. And now she's a happy camper. What more needs be said?

[racrawford65]

I agree with Bruce. I made the same change - from horizontal S2 to the Luna Duo. I found the same - better/clearer dialog. I am also using a pair of Rythmik E15s.

That said, I am upgrading to the Horizon with RAAL to match my Towers and because all the reviews are very positive on the Horizon. Originally, I didn't have room for the Horizon so that is why I went with the duo. But, figured I could either place the TV on top of the Horizon or build a new TV riser - I built the riser. So, just waiting on the Horizon to ship. Not sure whether to keep the Duo or sell it.

[Bruce Watson]

...I am upgrading to the Horizon with RAAL to match my Towers and because all the reviews are very positive on the Horizon.

Keep us posted. I'm thinking I'll have to upgrade my L/R pair to RAAL towers in the not so distant future, so I'll be very interested in how you hear the upgrade from Duo to Horizon. I'll bet I'm not the only one interested in what you find out.