Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 19

Thread: Hello and Advice Requested

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Apr 2016
    Posts
    12

    Question Hello and Advice Requested

    Hi, I am a musician and director of music at a church in the Houston, TX area. I, at one time, practiced law and was fortunate enough to build a decent two channel system based around the BEL 1001 MKV power amp and a Magnepan 1.6, with Vandersteen 2WQ sub. Then I married a beautiful lady whose dad was one of the on air engineers for the local NBC affiliate and TV and home theater immediately became a part of my life.

    Now, we have added a child and I seldom get to just sit and revel in audiophile bliss. I recently did add a DAC and mac mini music server for hi rez flac and DSD for those instances I get to listen. All of this stuff is in a really convoluted, messy set up in our living room. Magnepans, Vandersteen, BEL1001, Onkyo receiver, DirecTV box, Richard Gray 400 Pro, Mac, DAC....It is a mess. I think I will soon be able to update and modernize the whole set up. I have enjoyed this forum immensely as I have done research for the new system and before I ask my questions, I will commend this entire community for its spirit of helpfulness, patience, joy for audio and its lack of the negative, hostility that seems to infect so many online communities...Well Done.

    Here is what I have on my plate:
    1. Front end: Deciding between doing something like the Pioneer Elite SC-99 or the Marantz 7702 Mk2. If I go with the Marantz, I may buy some more BEL 1001s for separate power or maybe even some Outlaw 2200s...thoughts? Anyone with experience using a HT front end for 2 channel DAC critical listening?
    2. Finding surround connectivity options (We have a vaulted ceiling with no crawl space to run speaker cable from front end.)
    3. Speakers under consideration:
    - Pioneer Elite Atmos enabled Andrew Jones designed system
    - Tekton Lore Reference 5.0
    - Ascend system that cherry picks best speaker for application. RAAL Tower with Horizon? HTM or CBM for surrounds?
    4. Subs under consideration:
    - Hsu VTF-15H Mk2
    - Rhythmik 15 (no idea which)
    - Tekton Enzo or Cinema Sub
    - I am a little confused what the real world difference would be between an “audiophile” sub and a HT sub would be…

    I would really like some input/insight. No comment or observation is too detailed or simple. Can I really have good two channel AND HT performance without emptying my savings?
    How much consideration should I give to Atmos? I understand that there is not that much out now, but I will be living with system for the next 10-15 years.
    Lastly, is there any way to get descent, stable wireless connectivity where I can’t run a wire?

    The room is of large volume because the entire downstairs area is an open floor plan. The is a relatively open area that is roughly 25' x 58'. The front is the entry/dining area. The kitchen is in the middle with large counter and triple wide opening into the living area. The actual living/HT space is about 25' deep x 18' wide. The ceiling is sloped and fairly high 10' on two sides sloping up to almost 20'.

    Thank you in advance for your thoughts!

    Stan

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Feb 2016
    Posts
    457

    Default Re: Hello and Advice Requested

    You should contact Dave directly for his thoughts, he's extremely helpful and honest. You won't regret it.

    As for my two cents, you've got a lot of things to consider and you have certainly done your research in the same places I did on my journey to my setup. I too was really enamored with Tekton Design for a while, but after investigating I just couldn't take the plunge. Ascend's speakers have complex crossovers that correct for phase and time alignment, producing measurably incredible speakers that are intensely accurate and smooth at the same time. Tekton uses only a capacitor as a high pass filter to their tweeter, so I have read many complaints of them being imprecise and inaccurate. They are engineered for dynamics, not to be true to the source. They only list a couple of specs, and no +/- dB rating, whereas Ascend gives you tons of measurements and frequency response graphs with your towers. You also get bamboo cabinets instead of lightly braced wood cabinets.

    Tekton and HSU subs are really, really big and consume a lot of power. They're really easy to overdrive. Rythmik subs have servo technology that makes them never sound flubby or distorted like other subs. Rythmik really is something else when you sit down and compare a sub cranked up. Just go with whatever fits your budget, you'll be happy. I have two F12's and they fill my large room with intense, tight bass. Don't let the "audiophile" sub stuff fool you, they're all just trying to say they sound better than other subs out there.

    If you have a vaulted ceiling, atmos enabled speakers won'd do anything for you. They need a flat ceiling to reflect sound off of. It won't sound right without that flat ceiling.

    I have a Marantz AV7701 connected to an Emotiva XPA-5 Gen 2 and I'm really, really happy with it right now. Sounds pretty fantastic. If I was to upgrade, I'd get a system with better room correction, but that is way down the road. The 7702 gives you Atmos, so if you want that down the road when you have a room where you can mount speakers in the ceiling, then get that. I'm sure you'd be really happy with the outlaw amps with it as well.

    I have the Sierra Towers with RAAL tweeters and yes, you really can have amazing two channel AND HT performance. It's intense and beautiful. I couldn't be happier, and I didn't empty my savings at all.

    I think if you started off with the Sierra Towers and Horizon Center and a few HTM 200 SE's for surrounds you'd be incredibly happy. When you have a different room and/or want to add Atmost speakers, buy some more HTM 200 SE's and another amp and there ya go. Or, take a big plunge and buy Sierra Sats that are coming out soon, but those are going to be a lot more than the HTM 200 SE's.
    Last edited by sludgeogre; 05-01-2016 at 11:57 AM.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Apr 2016
    Posts
    12

    Default Re: Hello and Advice Requested

    Thanks Sludgeogre. I think at this point I have begun ruling out the Lores. The reason the Elite speakers are even in consideration is purely from a budget situation. I am wondering if I have some other things to accomplish around the house if the Andrew Jones designed Elites are a special enough speaker to justify spending a little less and upping the level in other areas.

    I am wondering whether I should do the vented or sealed sub(s)?

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Feb 2016
    Posts
    457

    Default Re: Hello and Advice Requested

    If you want to go for a more budget friendly setup, maybe go with Andrew Jones' new ELAC speakers instead of the Atmos enabled Pioneer ones. Those would be more sensible.

    They generally say to go with vented for HT primary use and sealed for music primary usage. I went with dual sealed as I just enjoy the extreme extension that sealed subs provide. Since you have a large area and you're going with one sub, I'd say go with a vented sub.

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Aug 2003
    Location
    Manhattan Beach, California
    Posts
    7,032

    Default Re: Hello and Advice Requested

    The Ascend CBM-170SE's and CMT-340SE's would be better options than the ELACs.
    -curtis

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Feb 2016
    Posts
    457

    Default Re: Hello and Advice Requested

    Quote Originally Posted by curtis View Post
    The Ascend CBM-170SE's and CMT-340SE's would be better options than the ELACs.
    Indeed, my bad, was just sticking with Andrew Jones for some reason. I have heard his budget Pioneer speakers and they are indeed fantastic, but not nearly as accurate, smooth, and impactful as the Ascend gear.

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Apr 2016
    Posts
    12

    Default Re: Hello and Advice Requested

    OK, thank you, that is valuable insight. I actually started my Ascend search with he CMT/CBM in mind, then I just kept reading. I am probably dealing with two basic issues here:
    1. I have been listening to a really strong combination of speakers and amp and I am afraid of what I may be giving up, and
    2. I have champagne taste and a church worker pocketbook.

    That is just something I guess I have to figure out on my end.

    I guess I have two options:
    1. Start with the CMT/CBM system, supplemented with Rythmik subs and upgrade the LCR later to RAAL tower/horizon, (then slide the CMT up to a flex room with second TV) or
    2. Forget about 3.1 or 5.1 at the moment and do a pair of RAAL towers, then add pieces as I go...

    What thoughts do you have about those options, is there a third I am missing?

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Feb 2016
    Posts
    457

    Default Re: Hello and Advice Requested

    As a Sierra Tower owner, I'm a bit biased, and I would recommend picking up the towers and adding a Horizon and Sierra Sats when you can afford them, but that's just me

    The towers are insanely good at everything, and I'm sure you'll be extremely happy with them as just a stereo pair until you can fill out your 5.1 set. I upgraded to my Towers from Magnepan Tympani 1D speakers, made in 1972. I did love those speakers, they have a huge soundstage and a really lush, sweet sound, but they lacked dynamic punch. My Sierra Towers with RAAL tweeters keep me enthralled with rich mids and insane impact. It's a night and day difference for me.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Aug 2003
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    5,538

    Default Re: Hello and Advice Requested

    Quote Originally Posted by curtis View Post
    The Ascend CBM-170SE's and CMT-340SE's would be better options than the ELACs.
    Completely agree - there is so much hype about the B5's and B6, but I need to state that other than the build quality (which is fantastic at this price point), I was not impressed by their performance, not even the slightest bit. I have much respect for Andrew Jones, some of you know might know that Jones was lead engineer on what is likely my favorite speaker, but these speakers were clearly designed for that typical mass market sound (in that regard they are very good) - but these are not what I would consider to be detailed speakers...
    .
    .
    .
    Good Sound To You!

    David Fabrikant
    www.ascendacoustics.com

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Apr 2016
    Posts
    12

    Default Re: Hello and Advice Requested

    You guys rock. OK, I am down to this:

    1. I have given up on doing a pre/pro with separates, I just don't have the cabinet space. I am down to wither the Denon AVR-X7200WA, Marantz SR7010 or I have not yet ruled out the Pioneer Elite SC-99. What do the esteemed wisemen, er people, on this forum think about those options?

    2. I am still torn on whether to start with RAAL towers only or go with CBM/CMT 5.0 with dual Rythmiks to establish multichannel audio, then switch out the CMTs later for RAAL towers and RAAL horizon. I would really like Dave's input on this one...

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •