Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 17

Thread: New to speakers, am I going to regret not getting the Sierra 2?

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    6

    Default New to speakers, am I going to regret not getting the Sierra 2?

    Hello, I am really new to audio speakers and always wanted my own surround set. I have a set of Ascend 340 CMT 340 L/C/R on the way but now I wonder if I should have just gotten a pair of Sierra 2 speakers instead. The price difference is big but is the quality difference so large that it would be worth it? Eventually I'd want to setup 5.1 but I am ordering it piece by piece until I can afford everything.

    Now I am new to speaker sets in general but I truly appreciate great sounding music, movies games etc. Truly accurate, authentic neutral sound is what I am hoping for. I really don't like it when it is too heavy on bass or treble. I want to enjoy what I am listening to as it was intended to be. If a set of Ascend 340 is enough then I feel much better about my purchase. Thank you in advance for any opinions/ideas!

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Nov 2011
    Posts
    394

    Default Re: New to speakers, am I going to regret not getting the Sierra 2?

    Quote Originally Posted by Sakome View Post
    Hello, I am really new to audio speakers and always wanted my own surround set. I have a set of Ascend 340 CMT 340 L/C/R on the way but now I wonder if I should have just gotten a pair of Sierra 2 speakers instead. The price difference is big but is the quality difference so large that it would be worth it? Eventually I'd want to setup 5.1 but I am ordering it piece by piece until I can afford everything.

    Now I am new to speaker sets in general but I truly appreciate great sounding music, movies games etc. Truly accurate, authentic neutral sound is what I am hoping for. I really don't like it when it is too heavy on bass or treble. I want to enjoy what I am listening to as it was intended to be. If a set of Ascend 340 is enough then I feel much better about my purchase. Thank you in advance for any opinions/ideas!
    You could order a pair of Sierra-2s, audition them, and the CMT 340s, and decide for yourself if they are worth the price difference. Return the ones you decide not to keep, and you're only out some shipping money, confident in a choice only you are qualified to determine.

    Jay

  3. #3
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Posts
    277

    Default Re: New to speakers, am I going to regret not getting the Sierra 2?

    Hi Sakome,

    What Jay said.

    If it were me and the money was there, no doubt it would be the Sierra 2. With the Sierra 2 you are near the very pinnacle of what a bookshelf speaker can achieve, but at a fraction of what this type of sound would usually cost. So there would be no second guessing down the road - something you are currently experiencing now hehe! There is also another critical factor: the Sierra 2's have high (as they say) WAF (Wife Approval Factor), if such a person were to enter the picture at some point. It's a speaker you would have no worries of a partner wishing they weren't there for aesthetic reasons. They are much smaller than the 340 CMTs, and of course look stunning like beautiful furniture. There is just so much amazing sound and looks put into a small volume! What the CMT's have going for them is what Curtis shared earlier - they may represent the biggest bang for the buck in Ascend's lineup.

    But to take the pressure off, it's not like you are committed to one or the other for life. I'm sure there are lots on this forum who have simply sold their Ascend speakers when the time was right and moved up the ladder to the Sierras.

    Mark

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    6

    Default Re: New to speakers, am I going to regret not getting the Sierra 2?

    Would a pair of Sierra 2 be enough without a Center and Subwoofer for awhile? That is one concern I did have which drew me away from them is it would take me quite some time to save up for a Center, Subwoofer and surrounds. I do have an AVR ready though (Yamaha rx-v 577).

    Not sure if it's another Sierra 2 or Sierra Horizon that is the better center but regardless, huge price difference than that of a 340

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Nov 2011
    Posts
    394

    Default Re: New to speakers, am I going to regret not getting the Sierra 2?

    Quote Originally Posted by Sakome View Post
    Would a pair of Sierra 2 be enough without a Center and Subwoofer for awhile? That is one concern I did have which drew me away from them is it would take me quite some time to save up for a Center, Subwoofer and surrounds. I do have an AVR ready though (Yamaha rx-v 577).

    Not sure if it's another Sierra 2 or Sierra Horizon that is the better center but regardless, huge price difference than that of a 340
    A center can be important in a home theater setting if some of the seating positions are substantially off center from the main speakers, phantom center imaging works quite well if you are seated close to the midway point between the two.

    I'm a fan of identical speakers across the front LCRs but the S-2s, and Sierra Towers/Horizon (w/RAALS) are so closely matched, either are very good choices for a center with either of the mains (IMHO).

    A good sub will definitely enhance the movie experience, and to a bit lesser degree, music. I think you'd be OK for a while without the sub if you're not accustomed to it, but once you get used to quality bass, you'll be hooked!

    Jay

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    6

    Default Re: New to speakers, am I going to regret not getting the Sierra 2?

    Quote Originally Posted by choirbass View Post
    Imaging as a phantom center is no problem, so a dedicated center isn't a dire need. For a sub, again not essential if they're run full range. The same reasoning as the center applies, as well.
    Sorry, I'm a real newbie when it comes to speakers. Not quite sure what you meant by this. Would these be options on my AVR to do this for the speakers? I can have my AVR tell it to act as a Center channel and how big of a range of sound they produce?

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    NW Pennsylvania
    Posts
    696

    Default Re: New to speakers, am I going to regret not getting the Sierra 2?

    Quote Originally Posted by Sakome View Post
    Sorry, I'm a real newbie when it comes to speakers. Not quite sure what you meant by this. Would these be options on my AVR to do this for the speakers? I can have my AVR tell it to act as a Center channel and how big of a range of sound they produce?
    All you would do is tell your AVR that you have only two speakers and no sub. The speakers will be set to 'Large' which means that all of the frequency range will be set to them. The Sierra's or 340's will probably surprise you with the amount of bass they can produce.
    Nate

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    6

    Default Re: New to speakers, am I going to regret not getting the Sierra 2?

    My set of Ascend 340s are here and I have been listening now for a couple days. At first my Yamaha RX-V 577 Yamaha kept shutting off when I turned it up but that may have been my fault. I had to redo the wires and it seems to be ok now.

    The highs and mids do sound nice if I have my AVR turned up a decent amount. It seems to be a bit lacking on low though but is that because I don't have a subwoofer? When I tried playing soundtracks with heavy Brass or bass, it wasn't as clear as I'd like. I don't have enough Banana plugs to plug in the Woofer bottom set yet to my AVR, would that be the problem?

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Posts
    291

    Default Re: New to speakers, am I going to regret not getting the Sierra 2?

    Quote Originally Posted by Sakome View Post
    My set of Ascend 340s are here and I have been listening now for a couple days. At first my Yamaha RX-V 577 Yamaha kept shutting off when I turned it up but that may have been my fault. I had to redo the wires and it seems to be ok now.

    The highs and mids do sound nice if I have my AVR turned up a decent amount. It seems to be a bit lacking on low though but is that because I don't have a subwoofer? When I tried playing soundtracks with heavy Brass or bass, it wasn't as clear as I'd like. I don't have enough Banana plugs to plug in the Woofer bottom set yet to my AVR, would that be the problem?
    How big is your room? The bigger the room the harder is for the speaker to fill in the low end.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Posts
    203

    Default Re: New to speakers, am I going to regret not getting the Sierra 2?

    Quote Originally Posted by choirbass View Post
    It's passive bi-amping, so additional separation and dynamics can be expected from powering them this way.
    Passive bi-amping cannot be expected to improve separation and dynamics.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •